|
|
Protection against unlawful failure to act in public administration
Hansel, Nona ; Mikule, Vladimír (advisor) ; Svoboda, Petr (referee)
A purpose of my thesis was an analysis of problems with legal regulation of protection against unlawful failure to act in public administration. Firstly I described institutes which should prevent illegal inactivity so I focused on regulations of time for taking a decision and other institutes, especially regulation presented by the Administrative Procedure Rules. The regulation in Administrative Procedure Rules caused a lot of questions which are nowadays answered thanks to the Highest Court of Administration and procedure according the Administrative Procedure Rules is connected with protection given by an administrative justice. In this system there is also included regulation of liability for damages caused by unlawful official procedure. The purpose of this institute is not to prevent inactivity but to compensate consequences it caused. The legislature completed this topic with a result that injured party can require (since 2006) compensation for suffering moral damage independently of property damage. We can find some positive elements of recent regulation, such as specific regulation of time for taking a decision, formulation of fundamental principles of action of administrative bodies or possibility to provide compensation of moral damages. But the regulation has imperfections too. Since basic...
|
|
|
Inaction in Proceedings before the Administrative Authorities
Adamec, Martin ; Prášková, Helena (advisor) ; Pítrová, Lenka (referee) ; Malast, Jan (referee)
Inaction in Proceedings before the Administrative Authorities - abstract The dissertation thesis deals with the issue of inactivity of administrative authorities in proceedings before them, which from the point of view of legal doctrine and application practice represents the most widespread form of inactivity in public administration. It can be considered as one of the most serious negative phenomena in public administration and its execution. Public administration is primarily seen as an executive (active) activity aimed at fulfilling its tasks set by or based on the legal order and carried out within its limits. As a rule, both legislation and scholarly literature contain material concerning public administration activities and their forms. The issue of inactivity often remains neglected, while in application practice it is a relatively common undesirable phenomenon, which the addressees of public administration encounter relatively often. The dissertation thus represents another source of reflection on this topic. The author interconnected two levels - theoretical and application, which allowed him to examine the issue of inactivity of administrative bodies in a broader context. There are often fundamental differences in approaches to legal doctrine and practice, but there is no reason to always have...
|
|
|
Protection against delays in administrative proceedings and in proceedings before administrative court
Koudele, Lukáš ; Kryska, David (advisor) ; Svoboda, Petr (referee)
Protection against delays in administrative proceedings and in proceedings before administrative courts Abstract The subject of this work are delays in administrative proceedings (where its legislation marks them as inaction) and before administrative courts. A delay is a state in which a certain act in the proceedings for some reason is not undertaken at the time within which it should be done. Reasons for delays may vary. They may be objective, which may consist of a number of cases that a person decides, whether it is due to insufficient staffing of the authorities in charge of the proceedings, or because of the deficiencies in the organization of work with that authorities, or may consist in the necessity of following the sequence of a process involving the necessity to perform an act that precedes the given operation. Reasons for delays can also be subjective, due to the lack of speed of work, either due to laziness or incompetence. The Charter of Fundamental Rights and Freedoms speaks of the duty to discuss the matter without unnecessary delays. This obligation applies both to administrative proceedings and to proceedings at the administrative courts. Since this is a law regulation, which applies to constitutional order, other legal norms can not contain a rule that would be inconsistent with the...
|
|
| |
|
|
Protection of Rights in Public Administration
Plisková, Hana ; Sládeček, Vladimír (advisor) ; Průcha, Petr (referee) ; Kopecký, Martin (referee)
1 Abstract The public administration itself is bound by applicable legal provisions. Therefore, in case of breach of individual rights stemming from the legal system of the Czech Republic, every person is guaranteed a strict legal procedure with corresponding legal mechanisms, which aim to remedy the status caused by unlawful action or inaction of the public administration. The object of this dissertation focuses, in particular, on analysis of individual means of protection of rights in public administration (i.e. the issue of the protection of public subjective rights) and their mutual relationships between them at level of legal regulation de lege lata. However, certain space had to be dedicated also to the procedures of public administration in matters related to private subjective rights as even the public administration decides on certain matters of private law. As regards the protection of private rights by public administration I mentioned the dualism of the review of decisions of public bodies and certain examples of public administration deciding on matters of private subjective rights. Further I stressed the issue of civil liability related to the conduct of public administration, i.e. liability for damages caused by unlawful decision and unlawful procedure. Pursuant to the act on liability for...
|
|
|
Protection of Rights in Public Administration
Plisková, Hana ; Sládeček, Vladimír (advisor) ; Průcha, Petr (referee) ; Kopecký, Martin (referee)
1 Summary The public administration itself is bound by applicable laws rules. Therefore, in case of breach of individual rights stemming from the legal system of the Czech Republic, every person is guaranteed a strictly legal procedure with corresponding legal mechanisms, which aim to remedy of status cause by unlawfull action or inaction of the public administration. Moreover, if conditions laid down by European Convention on the Protection of Human Rights and Fundamental Freedoms are met, an individual has a right to apply to the European Court of Human Rights (Strasbourg) for a revision of a challenged act of public administration, which is considered to be as a final and conclusive from the point of view of national law. The object of this Thesis focuses, in particular, on analysis of individual means of protection of rights in public administration and their mutual relationships between them at level of legal regulation de lege ferenda. Also, it cannot be disregarded the assessment of effect of courts' decisions or doctrine, including stating own knowledge based on the practice particularly in the area of administrative law. The Thesis focuses on the issue of the protection of individual public rights. As a consequence, legal means designed to provide protection of law in objective sense (that is...
|
|
|
Protection against unlawful failure to act in public administration
Hansel, Nona ; Mikule, Vladimír (advisor) ; Svoboda, Petr (referee)
A purpose of my thesis was an analysis of problems with legal regulation of protection against unlawful failure to act in public administration. Firstly I described institutes which should prevent illegal inactivity so I focused on regulations of time for taking a decision and other institutes, especially regulation presented by the Administrative Procedure Rules. The regulation in Administrative Procedure Rules caused a lot of questions which are nowadays answered thanks to the Highest Court of Administration and procedure according the Administrative Procedure Rules is connected with protection given by an administrative justice. In this system there is also included regulation of liability for damages caused by unlawful official procedure. The purpose of this institute is not to prevent inactivity but to compensate consequences it caused. The legislature completed this topic with a result that injured party can require (since 2006) compensation for suffering moral damage independently of property damage. We can find some positive elements of recent regulation, such as specific regulation of time for taking a decision, formulation of fundamental principles of action of administrative bodies or possibility to provide compensation of moral damages. But the regulation has imperfections too. Since basic...
|
guest ::
